1. Parenting

Readers Respond: How Long Did/Will Your Child's Car Seat Stay Rear-Facing? Why?

Responses: 134


Most car seat safety advocates recommend that toddlers stay rear-facing in their car seats until they reach the rear-facing limits of the seat. New research shows that toddlers are more than 5 times safer in the car if they stay rear-facing until age two! Are you a believer in extended rear-facing? When did you, or will you, turn your baby's car seat around? Why?

keep your child rear facing up to 5 year

That's what we do in Sweden, where the rear facing seats were invented in the 60 it's and where there are least mortal accidents involving children. Our car seats are rear facing up to 25 kg ( about 5 years). It's 500 % safer up to 2 years, please verify statistics on Swedish traffic safety and regulation sites. My boy is 3 and the argument that " he will hate it ", is simply lame bland lazy, the child follows the path his parents set out for him!! Our boy Oliver ( energetic, lively, bordering wild, to answer your questions) never questioned the fact he sits backwards and if he does - I will simply explain it to him. It's your kid and your choice but get the facts straight before taking a decision, it's worth your time. Ps he rides a pony, bike and rollers, so it's clear to wyomy mum! Oh, and one more this to the letter, if we did the same as our parents there would be no progress, I won't even get in on the mortality of kids or about of cars ( and their speed) in the passed
—Guest madie


It is not an "opinion" that rear-facing is safer, it is a scientific fact that has been proven through numerous studies. In fact, your child is 5 times safer rear-facing than forward- facing. It's basic physics. If you are chosing YOUR convenience over safety for your child, you can bet your bottom dollar I'm judging you. Nothing about parenting is convenient people! There have been NO recorded broken legs recorded in children rear-facing, and I would gladly take a broken leg bone or "alleged" pelvic damage over a broken neck and snapped spinal cord any day of the week. So research people. I do care about my child's comfort. More so, I care about their life. Also, I don't do things for my child because the law requires it. I don't feed my baby because the law says I have to I so because I love him. I don't RF because a law tells me to, I do it because science has prove it to be safer and until a newer development arises I will continue to follow recommendations.
—Guest Ash

You make me laugh little

Pelvic damage from rear facing!! Hahahahahahaha ok il stop now No wait.... Hahhahaha..... Did your friend leave her baby rear facing for hours and hours on end?
—Guest Yogabbagabba

Still rear-facing at 2 years

My almost 2 year old son is still rear faced in his car seat & he's only 23 lbs. He has a luxurious Britax seat that has side-impact cushions & is made to accommodate a 40 lb child & tilts lower to the back, so that he has more leg room. I drive a Toyota corolla (which is small in size), but my son is so comfy & snug, plus the car only allows for baby seats to be strapped in the middle of the back seats, so it's extra safe. If he's content, so am I, especially knowing he's more safe. This is how he'll stay until he's really reached the limit in size.
—Guest Tanya

Safest option

I didn't extended RF my older two, but after researching I decided it was the safest option, so my littlest is still RF and will be until he reaches the 40 pound limit for his carseat (we have the MyRide 65). He is a big baby, but it's not about size, it's about his bone development. His legs are fine and he doesn't know any different than rear facing.
—Guest Julie

rear face or front face?????

I understand the Reason of Rear facing carseat until the 2 year and 40lbs but It also depends on other circumstances as I know someone who's child had pelvic damage from being rear facing when the child legs were to long the only way in my eyes to keep a child rearfacing that long is to what cut a hole in your seat! How would you like to sit that way all the time when you go somewhere? If you have a short or petite child I am totally for the rear facing. A State Trooper told us if the childs legs are to long to turn them around hmmm listen to what they RECOMMEND or to a STATE TROOPER??? I choose the state trooper as My I have an old subburban and the old seatbelt would get in the way when trying to get her in or out of her seat so We were always hitting her head on the top of the truck, the carseat barely fit rear facing between the front seat and her carseat, She is tall and her legs were uncompfortable and it is not all in my head and My old vehicle is much safer then theese new one


My daughter is 14 months and I recently turned her seat to FF but after reading up on the issue I will switch back to RF. It's really enjoyable having her FF and she is much happier but it's much more of a safety issue than I first realized and it's not worth the risk. I've been in 3 car accidents in less than a year, rear-ended twice and once she was in the car with me but was ok.
—Guest Tree

RF till over 2 and to 35 lbs

I just bought a new convertible car seat that goes to 35 lbs RF for my grandson who is 20 mo. and 30 lbs . , he got too big to be RF in the infant seat I had for my car. I had his mom in a car seat 36 yrs ago after my father , who was a firefighter ,saw kids in car accidents that were in these things called "car seats" that stopped them from getting hurt. Car seats were hard to find 35yrs ago and the only ones who I knew who used them were people who were police, firefighters, ambulance drivers , ER workers and people they knew and told about these great things called car seats. If you want to know why you should keep your kids RF as long as you can, talk to first responders and ER workers . They are the ones that can tell you what a difference it can make, they see the damage and death that could have been avoided .
—Guest Diana


Our baby is still RF, but barely a year old. He is very tall for his age (32") and outgrowing his carseat by length. On the other hand, he is relatively trim at 19lbs. All the RF seats I've seen max out around 30" or 32", but the FF seats (and the law) want him to be 20lbs. We're not sure what to do here, but we'll be testing him in a FF seat to see whether the fit is okay, or if his low weight is a problem. **Editor's note - most high weight limit convertible car seats can accommodate a child of this height rear-facing. Just a few to try - Graco My Ride 65, Britax Boulevard 70, Diono Radian, The First Years True Fit.**
—Guest Guest Phil

The leading killer of children...

The leading killer of children are car accidents. Why not rear face a child until 4 years of age? Children in Sweden do this all the time! If you were to forward face a child before a 2, their neck could snap because children's bones are dense and aren't fused. Legs hitting the back of the seat are NOT a problem. In fact, broken legs are the most common injury for front facing children. This is because the child's legs and arms fly forward hitting the driver or passenger's seat in front of them. It is a myth- an old wives tale about children's legs breaking for longer rear facing. If a child's legs were to break when rear facing, then those forces are strong enough to break a young child's neck. If you have common sense, you will realize that broken necks are much more severe than broken legs.
—Guest Celine

carseats rear to front

i switched from rear to front when the kids legs were hanging over the infant seat my child was born in '93 and thats what they advised us to do back then my nephew who is 10 mos. is rear facing at 25 lbs. and after researching he will stay that way as long as possible.
—Guest a mom


Its nice that everyone wants to share oppinions. My kids both of them heathy little beans are stronger than most doctors! They both went forward at 12 months and I do.t regret or. I have never been in an accident but have avoided plenty. Doing what is best for your child or for u doesn't always mean going with what everyone else is doing. I'm happy and my kids are happy and I'm there protector.
—Guest jane

Almost 4 and still rear facing

I'm puzzled by the "I'm not doing anything illegal by FF, RF is only a recommendation" argument. Isn't this about choosing the safest option, not merely a legal one? My son is a few weeks from his 4th birthday and still rear facing. He's near the RF weight limit for his seat; I'm not sure whether we'll turn him forward or see if there is a seat available with a higher RF limit.
—Guest Duck n Monkey

I used to be a naysayer too

When the new requirement came out, I too used to say that's ridiculous! I won't do that! No way! Its my choice! Well, then I started wondering WHY the new recomendation was being made and decided to look at a few videos and read a few articles and I then understood. Its not about the carseat being unsafe. Its not about the car seat at all. Its about the crash forces on the childs head and spinal cord. A childs spinal cord isn't fully fused until about the age of 2, thus making it more easy to snap and not be able to handle the force of even many minor crashes. This isn't to say they can't sustain them, but I for one decided that MY child was not going to find out. My son is 18 months and is still rearfacing. I will evaluate his height and weight at 2 and decide if we will continue. But I'm now an extended rearfacing convert. As the saying goes: Broken leg, cast it. Broken neck, casket. I say-NOT MY CHILD!
—Guest lawgirl5


I am not doing anything wrong or illegal by FF my child at the appropriate weight and age. I have a certified seat...installed properly and my child is fastened safely. ERF is a recommendation only, not a law. Which means it is a CHOICE whether u want to do it or not. I’m sure there are many recommendations that we choose not to follow, even with our children. It is recommended we breastfeed....why? because it better and safer for our child....did we all breastfeed? NO.....it is recommended that we wait until they are 6 months old to feed them solids..... Why? because it is safer.....did we all wait? DOUBT IT. It is recommended that we not give them eggs, peanut butter, fish..etc. before they are 1....
—Guest FFmama
  1. About.com
  2. Parenting
  3. Baby Products
  4. Car Seats
  5. How Long Did Your Baby's Car Seat Stay Rear-Facing? Extended Rear-Facing Car Seats

©2015 About.com. All rights reserved.